Skip to main content
Rhiannon Tuckett-Jones
Rhiannon Tuckett-Jones
Research and Strategy Manager

This morning Alan Milburn published his much-anticipated final report, From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation. Its central argument is that the UK should move from a ‘Welfare State’ to a ‘Working State’, with youth participation as the central aim across education, health, welfare, and labour market policy. It sets out a 10-year programme to reduce the rate of young people not in education, employment, or training (NEET) to around 5 per cent by 2036, which the report calls ‘NEET Zero’. The first milestone is that no 16 to 17- year-old is NEET. 

Earlier this year, ahead of the interim report, we published our own report, Earning or Learning, and we have continued to explore the wraparound support needed to reduce the UK’s NEET rate effectively and sustainably. Next week we will meet members of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Skills, Careers and Employment (APGSCE) to hear their initial reactions to the report, and discuss reflections from employers, education providers, and policymakers. In the meantime, this blog sets out the report’s key recommendations and our initial takeaways. 

Employers and the labour market 

One of the report’s central premises is a ‘give and get’ bargain, in which government makes hiring young people easier, cheaper, and less risky, and employers create more first chances in return. Incentives include £3,000 for hiring a young person who has been NEET for six months, plus £2,000 premiums where the young person faces greater barriers (such as care leavers or disabled young people) and for businesses with fewer than 50 staff. 

These changes could be positive. Employers we have spoken to, especially small and medium enterprises (SMEs), describe hiring a young person as an increasing financial risk, at a time when artificial intelligence (AI) is driving up application numbers, often from overqualified candidates. Targeted support for youth hiring, with extra help for SMEs, could therefore be a welcome change. 

In regard to National Insurance (NI), the Milburn report rejects an across-the-board cut. Instead, when fiscal conditions allow, it proposes doubling the employer NI threshold from £5,000 to £10,000 for 21 to 24-year-olds starting in retail and hospitality. NI has been a point of debate since the 2024 Autumn Budget raised employer contributions. Employers argue the rise has limited their ability to hire, while others are concerned that a cut would be absorbed into profits or existing staff costs rather than used to create new roles. Targeting retail and hospitality, which together provide 37% of jobs for young people aged 16 to 24, focusses support where entry-level roles are most common. However, it will need to be matched by support to help young people access and sustain work, and by work that is stable and pays adequately.

Other recommendations include a statutory Youth Opportunity Test for major tax, spending, and regulatory decisions, a Youth Employment Cost Index published every two years, a target for 11 per cent of the Civil Service entry-level workforce to be aged 16 to 24 by 2032, and youth hiring as a mandatory Social Value criterion for public contracts over £5 million. The report also launches ‘First Chance’, an employer-led movement asking for more first jobs, youth apprenticeships, and work experience. 

Education and skills 

On education, the report sets prevention targets for 2036 of 90 per cent of children being school-ready at age five (the current target is 75 per cent) and 90 per cent reaching the expected standard in literacy and numeracy at the end of primary school. Risk of NEET Indicator (RONI) tools would become mandatory in primary and secondary schools. Other measures include a statutory key stage 3 writing, numeracy and oracy check, a move towards a single 14 to 19 framework covering academic and vocational learning, a statutory duty on schools to provide work experience, and a Ready-for-Work Standard inspected by Ofsted alongside a new school destination measure. Many of these echo the Skills Commission’s recommendations in Earning or Learning, which called for a stronger focus on early intervention and prevention, and for school accountability to give greater weight to vocational routes and young people’s transitions beyond school. 

Apprenticeships play a central part in the report and are named as “the largest education and skills priority”. It sets targets of 270,000 under-25 starts a year, and 35 per cent of each cohort starting an apprenticeship by age 25, both by 2036. The main vehicle is reform of the Growth and Skills Levy: the Treasury topslice would be abolished and under-25s would receive 100 per cent Levy funding, with less government funding for those over 25. 

This, alongside the employer incentives, is welcome, but it must come with proper mapping of employer capacity. Employers tell us that a limited pool of businesses is facing growing demand for placements, from T Level industry placements to supported internships and school-led work experience. Taking on a young person also brings real logistical and operational challenges, particularly in rural and coastal areas with fewer employers. As we have previously highlighted, reducing funding for over-25s also carries risks, particularly for older workers who need to retrain as the labour market changes. Our upcoming inquiry into apprenticeships will explore these issues in more detail. 

The report would also expand further education by an extra 150,000 18 to 24-year-olds a year, with colleges receiving a participation and work-readiness premium and funding moving towards rewarding outcomes. For higher education, it calls for prominent earnings data, more level 4 and 5 provision, easier progression from FE to HE, satellite campuses and civic models in places with low participation, and an ‘Open University for skills’. 

The additional investment in further education is welcome, as is the recognition of universities’ civic role. However, both depend on a financially stable sector, and FE and HE are under strain from cumulative policy changes, staff shortages and, for many universities, significant deficits and redundancies. These pressures, alongside increased competition between institutions, can also make partnerships harder to sustain. We will explore this in the Higher Education Commission’s upcoming inquiry into universities and their regional partnerships. 

Health 

On health, the report proposes that the NHS move from a ‘diagnose-wait-treat’ model to a ‘predict-prevent-participate’ model, in which support depends on need rather than diagnosis. Participation would be treated as a health outcome. Reducing NEET rates would become a formal objective for every Integrated Care Board (ICB), with a legal duty to work with mayoral strategic authorities. The report draws on the Fonagy Review, which found that the prevalence of ADHD and autism is ‘largely flat’ and that it is diagnosis that has risen. Others attribute the rise to better recognition of previously unmet need, and this is likely to be debated. Proposals include a universal digital mental health front door, fast-track access to Talking Therapies, vocational rehabilitation and IPS-Y, and Early Support Hubs in every upper-tier local authority.  

Many of these proposals depend on adequate access to services. Our report First Point of Care set out the policy changes needed to improve access to primary care, with recommendations on better connections between services and fairer distribution of funding. Embedding prevention into healthcare also requires better integrated training for new staff and a strong workforce pipeline. Our Trained for Tomorrow report, which assessed the education and training pathways for NHS staff, made a number of recommendations on how to achieve this. 

Welfare reform for under-25s 

The report’s welfare recommendations have attracted significant press coverage in the run-up to publication, with disagreement among Labour MPs, particularly after the government scaled back its earlier welfare proposals in 2025. The report is guided by the principle of “work for those who can, security for those who cannot”, and proposes a separate benefits system for under-25s. 

A statutory Opportunity Guarantee and Support Guarantee would cover all NEET 18 to 24-year-olds, whether or not they claim benefits, and the backstop of a paid six-month job would start after 12 months NEET rather than 18. A single Youth Allowance would be paid at the under-25 Universal Credit (UC) rate, with the UC health top-up and the Work Capability Assessment abolished for this group. Personal Independence Payments (PIP) would be replaced by an Additional Cost Allowance, alongside a local Health and Disability Fund, Severe and Complex Needs Insurance for those unlikely ever to work, and Child DLA extended to age 18. Under a new ‘duty to engage’, persistent refusal to engage could ultimately mean losing Youth Allowance, although the report says sanctions “should be rare”. 

Reducing the welfare bill has been an aim of successive governments and is increasingly complex. Earning or Learning highlighted how welfare support, including UC, can interact with training in ways that leave young people financially worse off for taking part, as well as wider problems with access and cliff edges. Many of these proposals aim to address those disincentives. However, any changes to welfare must be predicated on a guarantee of more opportunities and jobs, and on work that pays adequately. Without stronger wraparound support, including transport, housing stability, childcare, and access to opportunity, there is a risk of worsening existing challenges such as persistent debt. The Government’s response will show whether the proposals are workable and matched by the support young people need to enter and stay in work. 

A new participation system 

To address the fragmentation often reported across the system, the report proposes a Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) in every part of England by 2029, acting as one front door for young people and employers. Commissioned by mayors and built from existing services such as Jobcentre Plus youth support, Careers Hubs, and Youth Hubs, it would give young people a named adviser within 14 days and a Participation Plan within four weeks. Strategic authorities would take responsibility for 16 to 24- year-olds, ending the current cut-off at 18, supported by Area Youth Participation Plans, multi-year Participation Agreements with central government and shared data infrastructure. 

We welcome these recommendations. They closely mirror Earning or Learning‘s calls for stronger local delivery, including a locally led Youth Opportunity Fund, and for better data and local services to catch young people who fall through the gaps. They also reflect the challenges we have repeatedly raised through the APGSCE. Young people and employers have told us how difficult it is to navigate a crowded landscape of programmes and front doors, and how support too often falls away at 18. The service’s success will depend on whether strategic authorities receive the funding and capacity to match their new responsibilities. 

Conclusion 

Milburn’s final report is a wide-ranging assessment of the challenges facing young people, with recommendations that reach across multiple government departments. The timeline runs from the first 100 days, through 2027 (building the YOS, launching First Chance and legislation) and 2028 (education reforms), to 2029 (the new benefits system) and a fully statutory system in the early 2030s. The report’s own modelling projects a NEET rate of around 6.8 per cent by 2036, with the gap to 5 per cent dependent on higher economic growth and momentum in the youth labour market. 

Many questions remain, chief among them which recommendations the government will take forward and to what extent. Funding is central, with an initial £500 million drawn from reprioritised spending and further investment left to future Spending Reviews. Several proposals have already drawn both support and criticism, and the response from employers, education providers, health services, and young people will shape what happens next. 

We will be hosting a first reactions roundtable with the APGSCE next Monday, and the Review will feature across much of our upcoming work, including our apprenticeships inquiry, and the Higher Education Commission’s inquiry into universities and their regional partnerships. 

Cross-party forum

All-Party Parliamentary Group for Skills, Careers & Employment
See more from this group

More from Policy Connect

  • Insight

    Migration, Training, and Workforce Supply in Health and Social Care

    16 November 2026 by Max Bishop
  • Event

    Online Roundtable: Milburn Review First Reactions

    Event date: 23 November 2026
  • Insight

    MPs Debate the Interim Milburn Review

    12 November 2026 by Max Bishop